5 Signs Your Site Looks Good—but Isn’t Converting

You spent hours making your site look clean, pretty, and maybe even bougie. But here’s the cold truth: aesthetics don’t equal conversions. Just because your site looks good doesn’t mean it’s doing its job. The job? To get people to take action—click, buy, book, inquire. So if your site is all style and no strategy, let’s talk about why that “fresh” design still isn’t bringing in the sales.

Here are 5 glaring red flags that your cute little site might be secretly sabotaging your business.

1. You’re Getting Traffic, But No One’s Buying

You’re out here promoting, posting, maybe even paying for ads. And according to your analytics, people are actually landing on your site. But they’re bouncing faster than a bad date. What gives?

This usually means one of two things: your visitors aren’t seeing what they expected when they landed on your site, or they’re confused about what to do next. The visual design might be nice, but if it’s not aligned with your messaging and offer, your audience will peace out.

Conversion Tip: Make sure your homepage headline and hero image match what you’re promoting on social or in ads. Relevance is queen.

2. Your CTAs Are Confusing (Or Missing Altogether)

If your site visitors don’t know what to do next, guess what they do? They leave. Calls-to-action (CTAs) should be loud, clear, and compelling. But too many websites hide the CTA like it’s a dirty secret.

“Learn More” and “Click Here” are lazy. They don’t tell the visitor why they should click, or what they’ll get.

Conversion Tip: Use CTA buttons that finish this sentence: “I want to…” (e.g., “Book My Free Consult,” “Fix My Website,” “Get the Mini Kit”). Make the benefit obvious.

3. Mobile View Is a Disaster

Here’s a harsh reality: more than 60% of web traffic now comes from mobile devices. If your site looks great on desktop but breaks on mobile, you’re basically ghosting your biggest audience.

Common mobile disasters:

  • Tiny unreadable text
  • Overlapping images or buttons
  • Navigation menus that don’t work

Conversion Tip: Test your site on multiple devices. Your site should feel just as polished on a phone as it does on a MacBook.

4. Your Copy Is Cute But Confusing

You’ve got clever taglines and quirky jokes—love that for you. But if someone lands on your homepage and can’t figure out what you do in 5 seconds or less, it’s game over.

Your copy needs to:

  • Clearly explain what you offer
  • Speak directly to your ideal client
  • Guide them to the next step

Conversion Tip: Ask a friend (not in your biz) to visit your site and explain what you do. If they struggle? You need a rewrite.

5. It Looks Great, But It’s Not Doing Anything

You’ve got the bells, the whistles, the parallax scrolling, the muted blush tones. Cool. But design without strategy is just digital clutter.

A well-designed site:

  • Has intentional structure
  • Guides the visitor down a journey
  • Answers questions before they’re asked
  • Builds trust through testimonials, visuals, and voice

If your site is more of a pretty brochure than a strategic tool, you’re missing out on conversions.

The Big Picture

Conversion isn’t just about slapping on a better headline or moving a button. It’s about understanding the user journey, what your audience needs, and how your site can meet them there. You need to stop designing “for vibes” and start designing for action.

And no, you don’t have to burn your whole website down. That’s why I created the Website Refresh—for business owners who just need to clean up the digital chaos, not start from scratch.

Let’s Fix It

This isn’t about perfection. It’s about performance. If you’re tired of having a site that looks good but delivers nothing, let’s fix it together.

[Book Your Website Refresh Now] and turn that “pretty but pointless” homepage into a real sales tool.

 

Back to blog